The FCC logged 1,595 complaints about loud TV commercials between January 1 and November 7, 2026, already more than the 1,420 it recorded in all of 2025 (FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data, queried November 8, 2026). The problem the CALM Act was meant to solve fourteen years ago has not gone away: in December 2012, the month the rules took effect, viewers filed 4,777 complaints (NextTV, reporting the Commission’s report to Rep. Anna Eshoo, 2014). Standards bodies are still moving, with ATSC publishing the first comprehensive revision of its A/85 loudness practice since 2013 on July 15, 2026 (ATSC, A/85 Revision Press Release 2026). Meanwhile, a 2026 measurement study found two ads on the same Polish streaming service that differed by more than 13 LU (Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study). We aggregated data from the FCC consumer complaints dataset and ECFS docket, ATSC, the EBU, Spain’s CNMC, the UK’s BCAP code and DPP delivery spec, Australia’s ACMA, and peer-reviewed measurements; for the platform-side targets used by music and podcast services, see our companion roundup on streaming audio loudness normalization.
A quick glossary: LKFS and LUFS are two names for the same ITU-R BS.1770 loudness scale, and one LU (loudness unit) is a 1 dB step on that scale. True peak (dBTP) is the highest level of the reconstructed waveform, the number that decides whether a signal clips after coding.
TL;DR
- 1,595 loud-commercial complaints from January 1 to November 7, 2026, versus 1,420 in all of 2025 (FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data 2026).
- Loud commercials were 9.1% of all TV complaints in 2025, the fourth-largest TV issue after billing, availability and indecency (FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data 2025).
- Monthly complaints fell 86% in the first year of the rules, from 4,777 in December 2012 to 656 in December 2013 (NextTV, reporting the Commission’s report to Rep. Eshoo, 2014).
- The FCC had never brought a CALM Act enforcement action as of August 2020 (TV Technology 2021, reporting Chairman Pai’s letter).
- ATSC A/85:2026 keeps -24 LKFS as the target with a tolerance of about plus or minus 2 dB (ATSC A/85:2026-07).
- The new A/85 streaming annex recommends a single target between -23 and -27 LKFS (ATSC A/85:2026-07, Annex L).
- EBU R 128 s1 caps short-term loudness of adverts at -18.0 LUFS, 5 LU above the -23.0 LUFS target (EBU R 128 s1 2020).
- 80% of responses to Spain’s 2025 consultation backed perceived-loudness measurement under R 128 (CNMC INF/DTSA/083/25).
- A Spotify ad measured at about -5.8 LUFS, roughly 8 LU above the declared -14 LUFS requirement (Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study).
- Listener ratings of ad loudness tracked the measured LUFS differences with R = 0.89 (Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study).
1. The Launch Wave: CALM Act Complaints in 2012 and 2013
The CALM Act (Commercial Advertisement Loudness Mitigation Act) did not create the complaints; it created a place to send them. Before the rules took effect, the FCC counted only 192 loud-commercial complaints in the third quarter of 2012. Once a dedicated form went live, the floodgates opened: December 2012 alone produced more complaints than the open complaints dataset in section 2 records for any full year since 2015. Monthly complaints then fell 86%, from 4,777 in December 2012 to 656 in December 2013 (NextTV, reporting the Commission’s report to Rep. Anna Eshoo, 2014; (4,777 - 656) / 4,777 = 86%).
Read the curve as two things at once. Part of the drop is real compliance, since stations and pay-TV distributors (cable and satellite companies, which the FCC calls MVPDs) had to install loudness meters and processing. Part of it may be fatigue: viewers who complained once and saw nothing happen had little reason to file again. The enforcement record in section 3 makes that second reading hard to dismiss.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Loud-commercial complaints in the third quarter of 2012, before the rules took effect | 192 | TV Technology 2013, reporting the Commission’s letter to Rep. Eshoo |
| Complaints in December 2012 (rules effective December 13) and in January 2013 | 4,777 and 4,405 | TV Technology 2013 |
| Complaints in March 2013 and in May 2013 | 1,526 and 1,065 | TV Technology 2013 |
| Complaints from December 13, 2012 to June 5, 2013 referred to the Enforcement Bureau vs set aside as incomplete | 10,700 (roughly two-thirds) vs 5,150 | TV Technology 2013 |
| Financial-hardship and general waiver requests from TV stations, and how many were granted | 170 requested, all 170 granted | TV Technology 2013 |
| Total complaints in the first year after enforcement began | more than 20,000 | NextTV 2014, reporting the Commission’s report to Rep. Eshoo |
| Share of first-year complaints referred to the Enforcement Bureau | 70% | NextTV 2014 |
| Complaints filed in calendar year 2013, the all-time peak | 16,310 | TV Technology 2020, reporting Chairman Pai’s letter |
Context note: the 2013 figures come from FCC letters to Congress as described by trade press; the letters themselves were not available to us. The waivers let stations delay compliance by up to two one-year periods. Most recent available data for this launch period: trade-press reports from 2013 and 2014.
2. FCC Loud-Commercial Complaints by Year, 2014 to 2026
The FCC’s open consumer complaints dataset, which starts on October 31, 2014, carries a “Loud Commercials” category under TV, and it tells a story the 2013 decline does not. Complaints never returned to pre-rule levels. They swung between about 1,400 and 4,400 a year, with a pandemic-era rise to 3,937 in 2021 and a second spike in 2024. May 2024 brought 461 complaints, the fourth-highest month in the whole series, and the 2024 total of 2,665 was 42% above 2023’s 1,877 (FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data 2024; 2,665 / 1,877 = 1.42).
The 2026 number matters most. With almost two months left, the year has already passed the 2025 total, and loud ads hold a steady 9.1% share of all TV complaints. The steady share cuts both ways: loud ads are rising in step with TV complaints overall rather than outpacing them, yet they remain roughly one TV complaint in eleven, a decade after the rules were supposed to settle the issue.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Loud-commercial complaints per year, 2015 / 2016 / 2017 / 2018 | 4,401 / 2,997 / 3,183 / 3,380 | FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data, queried November 8, 2026 |
| Loud-commercial complaints per year, 2019 / 2020 / 2021 / 2022 | 1,877 / 2,880 / 3,937 / 3,109 | FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data 2026 |
| Loud-commercial complaints per year, 2023 / 2024 / 2025 / 2026 (January 1 to November 7) | 1,877 / 2,665 / 1,420 / 1,595 | FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data 2026 |
| Loud commercials as a share of all TV complaints, 2025 and 2026 to November 7 | 9.1% (1,420 of 15,522) and 9.1% (1,595 of 17,607) | FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data 2026 |
| 2019 complaint count stated by the FCC Chairman in August 2020 (cross-check against the dataset) | 1,877 | TV Technology 2020, reporting Chairman Pai’s letter |
Context note: the dataset holds informal complaints as the consumer filed them; the FCC states that it does not verify the facts alleged. Over the decade, 2025’s 1,420 was 68% below 2015’s 4,401 (1,420 / 4,401 = 0.32). The 2025 share uses the seven named TV issues plus blank entries as the denominator.
3. Enforcement, Spot Checks and the 2025 Rulemaking
The CALM Act rules are built on certification, not inspection. Networks certify that their programming complies, stations rely on those certifications, and the largest operators run annual spot checks: 24-hour recordings of a channel’s audio, measured against the target. Paperwork goes to the FCC only when it opens an inquiry into a pattern or trend of complaints. The outcome is predictable: as of August 11, 2020, the FCC had never brought an enforcement action under the CALM Act (TV Technology 2021, reporting Chairman Pai’s reply to Rep. Eshoo).
That record is the backdrop for MB Docket 25-72, the rulemaking the FCC opened in February 2025 to ask whether its rules still work and whether it has any authority over streaming (Federal Register notice, March 11, 2025). The filing mix tells you who cares: the docket is dominated by express comments (one-paragraph public comments typed straight into the FCC’s online form), while broadcasters argue the problem now lives on streaming platforms. Streaming is also where newer accessibility duties have landed, as our roundup on audio description quotas for streaming and TV shows.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| CALM Act enforcement actions brought by the FCC, as of the Chairman’s August 11, 2020 letter | none | TV Technology 2021, reporting Chairman Pai’s letter |
| Filings in MB Docket 25-72 as of November 2026: total / comments / express comments | 169 / 159 / 139 (express comments are 82% of filings) | FCC ECFS, MB Docket 25-72, queried November 8, 2026 |
| Estimated annual channel spot checks under the CALM Act rules, and who must run them | 2,038 spot checks by 107 respondents (92 of 1,390 commercial TV stations, 4 very large and 11 large cable or satellite distributors); a check fails if average loudness exceeds the target by more than 2 dB | FCC Supporting Statement, OMB Control No. 3060-1171, November 2026 |
| Position of the National Association of Broadcasters in the 2025 docket | the majority of consumer complaints about ad volume stem from streaming services (trade group’s own claim) | Broadband Breakfast 2025, reporting NAB comments |
Context note: the same supporting statement estimates 6,036 burden hours a year across all CALM Act recordkeeping, a modest load spread over 2,937 broadcasters and distributors. The NAB did not publish a count behind its streaming claim in the coverage we read.
4. ATSC A/85 Targets and Tolerances After the 2026 Revision
A/85 is the recommended practice the CALM Act made binding for US broadcasters, and its July 2026 revision is the first comprehensive update since 2013. The numbers that matter for ads did not move: -24 LKFS, a tolerance of about 2 dB either way, and a true-peak ceiling below -2 dBTP. What changed is scope. A new streaming annex recommends that each service pick one consistent target between -23 and -27 LKFS (ATSC A/85:2026-07, Annex L), which gives streamers a broadcast-grade benchmark for the first time.
One detail helps explain why complaints persist. For long programmes, A/85 measures the anchor element, normally the dialogue, while for ads it measures the full mix. A drama with quiet dialogue can sit at -24 LKFS on paper, and a fully compressed ad can sit at -24 LKFS too, yet the ad still feels louder after a quiet scene. Teams moving broadcast plants to IP still meter against these same targets, as our AoIP broadcast migration roundup notes.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Target loudness for content delivered without metadata | -24 LKFS | ATSC A/85:2026-07, Section 6 |
| Anticipated measurement tolerance around the target | up to approximately plus or minus 2 dB | ATSC A/85:2026-07, Section 6 |
| True-peak ceiling and its meter tolerance | below -2 dBTP, plus or minus 0.5 dBTP | ATSC A/85:2026-07, Section 6 |
| What is measured for short-form content such as ads vs long-form programmes | always the full-program mix for ads vs typically the dialogue for programmes | ATSC A/85:2026-07, Section 5.2 |
| Comfort Zone (the range of loudness change that A/85 treats as acceptable to viewers), relative to the target | +2.4 dB to -5.4 dB | ATSC A/85:2026-07, Section 3.4 |
| Streaming annex: recommended target and delivery tolerance | one target between -23 and -27 LKFS; content within plus or minus 2 dB of the channel target | ATSC A/85:2026-07, Annex L |
Context note: ATSC announced the revision on July 15, 2026 and describes it as the first comprehensive update since 2013 (ATSC press release). A/85 is a recommended practice: it binds US broadcasters only because the CALM Act rules incorporate it by reference.
5. EBU R 128 for Adverts and Regulation in Continental Europe
Europe solved the measurement problem differently: one programme loudness for everything, plus a separate cap on short bursts. EBU R 128 s1 limits short-term loudness of adverts, trailers and promos to -18.0 LUFS, only 5 LU above the -23.0 LUFS target (EBU R 128 s1, 2020). The EBU states the reason in plain terms: overly dynamic short-form items “would lead to audience complaints”. A US ad can be compliant on average and still spike; an R 128 s1 ad cannot spike far.
Adoption came country by country rather than through one EU rule. France tied R 128 to its audiovisual legislation in 2011, Germany and Austria switched in September 2012, and Spain is still writing the detail. Its regulator, the CNMC, adopted supervision criteria on November 20, 2025, after a public consultation that drew only 10 responses.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| EBU R 128 s1 programme loudness for adverts and promos, and measurement tolerance | -23.0 LUFS, plus or minus 0.2 LU | EBU R 128 s1 (version 3, August 2020) |
| EBU R 128 s1 maximum true peak and its measurement tolerance | -1 dBTP, plus or minus 0.3 dB | EBU R 128 s1 (version 3, August 2020) |
| France: first country to link R 128 to audiovisual law; date short programmes had to be normalised | October 2011; from January 1, 2012 | EBU news, October 2011 |
| Germany and Austria: date broadcasters began applying R 128 | September 2012 (opening of IFA Berlin) | EBU news, September 2012 |
| Spain: responses to the CNMC consultation, and share backing perceived-loudness measurement under R 128 | 10 responses; 80% in favour; 60% aligned with -23 LUFS | CNMC INF/DTSA/083/25, November 2025 |
| Spain: loudness for digital terrestrial TV under Real Decreto 250/2025 | -23.0 LUFS, plus or minus 1.0 LU | CNMC INF/DTSA/083/25, 2025 |
| Spain: legal class of a breach of the ad sound-level rule (article 121.4, General Audiovisual Communication Law) | minor infraction (article 159.8) | CNMC INF/DTSA/083/25, 2025 |
Context note: the EU Audiovisual Media Services Directive sets no numeric sound-level limit for ads, according to the CNMC document. The CNMC opened its consultation on March 28, 2025 (CNMC press release) and says it had received viewer complaints, without publishing a count.
6. UK and Australian Rules and Complaint Records
The UK and Australia regulate ad loudness through codes rather than statute, and neither publishes a running loudness complaint count that we could find. In the UK the operative rule is BCAP Code rule 4.7: TV ads “must not be excessively noisy or strident” (ASA, BCAP Code Section 4). The most recent public UK complaint count we found is 245 complaints about noisy TV ads between September 2005 and December 2006 (Out-Law, Pinsent Masons 2007, reporting a BCAP consultation). In 2016 the ASA said only that it had received “significant numbers of complaints” where loudness was poorly matched (ASA 2016).
Where the UK is precise is at the delivery desk. The DPP commercial delivery spec, used by the UK broadcasters that adopt it to accept or reject ads, follows R 128 s1 and adds an automatic failure on true peak. Australia relies on self-certification: the person submitting a commercial certifies compliance, and the ACMA investigates individual cases, such as a 2018 complaint about a Nine broadcast.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| BCAP rule 4.7 fallback when a peak programme meter is used instead of loudness metering | ad maximum at least 6 dB below programme maximum | ASA, BCAP Code Section 4 |
| ASA complaints about the perceived noisiness of TV ads, September 2005 to December 2006 | 245 | Out-Law, Pinsent Masons 2007, reporting BCAP consultation |
| UK commercial delivery loudness under DPP012 version 2.0 (dated May 17, 2025) | -23.0 LUFS plus or minus 0.2 LU; short-term maximum -18.0 LUFS | DPP012 v2.0, Digital Production Partnership |
| UK commercial true-peak recommendation vs automatic failure level | recommended -3 dBTP; content fails above -1 dBTP | DPP012 v2.0, 2025 |
| Australia: reference loudness for commercials under Free TV OP-48 | -24 LKFS | ACMA Investigation BI-429, 2018 |
| Australia: outcome of ACMA’s loud-ad investigation into a Nine broadcast of February 17, 2018 | no breach of Code clause 5.7.2 | ACMA Investigation BI-429, 2018 |
| Australia: how a broadcaster meets Code clause 5.7.2 on commercial loudness | certification of compliance by the person submitting the commercial | Free TV Code review, revised Code mark-up, September 2024 |
Context note: most recent available data for UK complaint volumes is the 2007 BCAP consultation figure. Free TV reports Code complaint totals to the ACMA each year, but we could not reach a public breakdown that isolates loudness complaints.
7. Measured Loudness Jumps Between Programmes and Ads
Complaints tell you people are annoyed; meters tell you why. The best recent measurement comes from a 2026 study of 15 advertisement and programme pairs captured from Polish streaming and on-demand services and rated by 30 listeners (n = 30, aged 23 to 54). One Spotify ad played at about -5.8 LUFS, roughly 8 LU above the declared -14 LUFS requirement and more than 7 LU above the accompanying programme material (Electronics 2026, 15(17), 4031). The authors report that exploratory checks of foreign platforms showed a similar picture.
The study also shows that the meter and the ear agree. Listener ratings tracked the LUFS gaps closely, except among the 9 listeners who reported hearing problems, whose ratings matched far less well. Small level gaps are also more audible than most people assume, a point covered in our roundup on loudness just-noticeable differences. Broadcast TV in Spain shows the same pattern in sound-pressure terms: a journalist’s meter readings put the quietest moment of an ad break 8.5 to 19.5 dB above the quietest moment of the programme.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Study sample: advertisement and programme pairs, and listeners | 15 pairs; 30 listeners aged 23 to 54 | Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study |
| Correlation between listener ratings and measured LUFS differences | R = 0.89 | Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study |
| Spotify ad loudness vs declared platform requirement | about -5.8 LUFS vs -14 LUFS (about 8 LU above) | Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study |
| Loudness gap between two ads on the same service (cda.pl) | more than 13 LU (-12.1 LUFS vs -25.5 LUFS) | Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study |
| Correlation for listeners reporting hearing problems (n = 9) vs no hearing problems (n = 21) | 0.57 vs 0.90 | Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study |
| Ads marked in the study’s results table as meeting the -23 LUFS target | 6 of 15 | Electronics 2026, Internet Advertisement Loudness Study |
| Spain: quietest ad-break level minus quietest programme level, A-weighted sound level meter, April 2025 | 19.5 dB (Antena 3), 15.4 dB (Telecinco), 8.5 dB (TV3) | Ara, April 25, 2025, journalist’s own measurements |
Context note: the study’s sample is small and the authors call the hearing-group results exploratory; hearing status was self-reported. The Ara readings are in dB SPL from a room meter, depend on the TV volume setting, and are not LUFS values, so they cannot be compared directly with the study’s figures.
Summary: TV Commercial Loudness (CALM Act) Complaints by the Numbers
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| FCC loud-commercial complaints, January 1 to November 7, 2026 vs all of 2025 | 1,595 vs 1,420 | FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data 2026 |
| Filings in MB Docket 25-72, November 2026 (express comments) | 169 (139) | FCC ECFS 2026 |
| Complaints in calendar year 2013, the all-time peak | 16,310 | TV Technology 2020 |
| Monthly complaints, December 2012 vs December 2013 | 4,777 vs 656 | NextTV 2014 |
| CALM Act enforcement actions as of August 2020 | none | TV Technology 2021 |
| ATSC A/85:2026 target and tolerance | -24 LKFS, about plus or minus 2 dB | ATSC A/85:2026-07 |
| EBU R 128 s1 short-term loudness cap for adverts | -18.0 LUFS | EBU R 128 s1 2020 |
| EBU R 128 s1 programme loudness and true peak for adverts | -23.0 LUFS; -1 dBTP | EBU R 128 s1 2020 |
| France linked R 128 to audiovisual law | October 2011 | EBU 2011 |
| Spain CNMC consultation responses backing perceived loudness | 80% of 10 | CNMC INF/DTSA/083/25 |
| Spain digital terrestrial TV loudness | -23.0 LUFS, plus or minus 1.0 LU | CNMC INF/DTSA/083/25 |
| Spain legal class of an ad sound-level breach | minor infraction | CNMC INF/DTSA/083/25 |
| UK BCAP peak-meter rule for ads | at least 6 dB below programme maximum | ASA, BCAP Code Section 4 |
| UK DPP commercial automatic true-peak failure | above -1 dBTP | DPP012 v2.0, 2025 |
| Australia OP-48 commercial reference loudness | -24 LKFS | ACMA BI-429, 2018 |
| Spotify ad loudness above declared requirement | about 8 LU | Electronics 2026 |
| Loudness gap between two ads on one service | more than 13 LU | Electronics 2026 |
| Spain ad-break floor above programme floor, Antena 3 | 19.5 dB | Ara 2025 |
Methodology and Sources
We ran targeted searches in November 2026 and read every primary document or publisher page listed below. FCC complaint counts were pulled directly from the FCC open data API (Socrata) on November 8, 2026, filtering the issue field to “Loud Commercials”; docket counts come from the FCC ECFS public API on the same day. Derived figures (the 86% first-year fall, the 42% rise in 2024, the 68% decade decline, the 9.1% shares and the 82% express-comment share) show their arithmetic in the text.
- FCC CGB Consumer Complaints Data, Federal Communications Commission, dataset updated November 8, 2026.
- FCC ECFS filings in MB Docket 25-72, docket filings accessed November 8, 2026.
- Federal Register notice of the CALM Act Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (FCC 25-16, MB Docket 25-72), March 11, 2025.
- FCC Supporting Statement for the CALM Act information collection, OMB Control No. 3060-1171, November 2026.
- TV Technology, CALM Act facts revealed, July 7, 2013 (FCC letter to Rep. Eshoo); TV Technology, Rep. Eshoo Challenges FCC Action on CALM Act, August 27, 2020; TV Technology, Eshoo Calls for FCC Investigations into CALM Act Complaints, April 14, 2021.
- NextTV, FCC: Commercial Loudness Complaints Steadily Decrease, January 30, 2014.
- Broadband Breakfast, NAB to FCC: Online Video Streamers Causing Loud Commercials, April 11, 2025.
- ATSC A/85:2026-07 Recommended Practice and ATSC press release, July 15, 2026.
- EBU R 128 s1, Loudness Parameters for Short-form Content, version 3, August 2020; EBU loudness hub; EBU news items from October 2011 and September 2012.
- CNMC INF/DTSA/083/25, sound-level supervision criteria, November 20, 2025, and CNMC consultation press release, March 28, 2025.
- ASA, BCAP Code Section 4 and ASA, Sound levels in advertising, April 13, 2016.
- Out-Law (Pinsent Masons), TV ads sound too loud and rules should change, says regulator, June 4, 2007.
- DPP012 version 2.0, Commercial, Sponsorship and Infomercial Delivery Guidance, Digital Production Partnership, 2025.
- ACMA Investigation Report BI-429, November 6, 2018, and Free TV Australia revised Code of Practice mark-up, September 2024.
- Objective and Subjective Assessment of the Loudness of Internet Advertisements, Electronics 2026, 15(17), 4031, funded by the Faculty of Electronics, Telecommunications and Informatics, Gdańsk University of Technology.
- Ara, The fight against blaring ads is underway, Albert Cuesta, April 25, 2025.
- Data watch: the FCC’s own NPRM (FCC 25-16) counts “at least 1,700” loud-commercial complaints in 2024, about 825 in 2023 and about 750 in 2022, far below the 2,665, 1,877 and 3,109 in the open dataset’s Loud Commercials category; the NPRM does not explain the counting rule in the passage we read, so treat the two series as different measures and do not mix them. The dataset’s 2019 total (1,877) matches the figure the FCC Chairman gave Congress in 2020, and 2023 happens to show the same 1,877 (we re-queried both years). The dataset records no loud-commercial complaints at all for October 2025 and only 66 in November 2025, most likely a gap in intake rather than a quiet month (the dataset gives no reason), so the 2025 total is probably understated. The 2014 figure (587) covers only November and December. The 2013 counts reach us through trade press describing FCC letters; NextTV’s “more than 20,000” first-year total and TV Technology’s 16,310 for 2013 cover different windows. Ara’s claim that 3 dB doubles perceived loudness conflicts with the Electronics paper’s rule of thumb (about 10 dB per doubling), so we used neither as a headline. No final order in MB Docket 25-72 appeared in the documents we read.
Last updated: November 8, 2026. We update this roundup quarterly, and the next refresh is expected when the FCC acts on MB Docket 25-72 or publishes its first full-year 2026 complaint data.